CHESTNUT HILL, Mass. — Nate Sweet (Darien, Conn.) could be playing Division 1 college lacrosse.
The former Brunswick star received offers from Division 1 programs in his recruiting process. The 6-foot-1 defender played on one of the top prep teams in the country. He is very skilled. He was the full package for a recruiter.
There is a real glamour to committing to play at the NCAA level. It is often the ultimate goal of the top players in the region. But for Sweet, there was more to the picture.
“I wasn’t going to go to a school (just for lacrosse) when I knew I could go to a better school,” Sweet said.
Sweet said the Division 1 offers he did receive weren’t at the academic level he was looking for. There was one school, however, that was a “unicorn.”
Boston College.
The Eagles don’t offer a men’s lacrosse team at the NCAA level. They once did, but the program was nixed in 2002. Some might view that as a dealbreaker. Sweet did not. He is only a few months into his time at Boston College as a member of the school’s men’s club lacrosse team, but he has already immersed himself in the experience he hoped he would get while playing lacrosse in college. And he represents a growing population of players who are choosing club over NCAA for the same reasons.
“The club team is really serious, because there’s no Division 1 team,” Sweet said. “This is it on campus…It’s the real thing.”
READ MORE: Two BC alums aiming for spots on Team USA at ’28 Olympics
The team practices twice a week in the fall, utilizing Alumni Field — the 44,500-capacity stadium that is home to the school’s ACC football team — as well as Fish Field House, a state-of-the-art indoor turf facility built for Division 1 athletes and teams on campus.
“You’re still getting these high-level facilities,” said freshman Tommy Onderdonk. “Not many people get to play in the main football stadium and the Fish Field House like this. Even high Division 1 programs don’t get this.”
Like Sweet, Onderdonk, a West Chester, Pa., native, received interest from Division 1 programs in his recruiting process. As a senior, Onderdonk was a starting attackman at Malvern Prep and led his team to a state championship. There is a Division 1 pedigree within his family, too. His uncle played at BC when the program was Division 1.
But Onderdonk valued high-end academics. He felt BC provided that.
“Lacrosse in college is definitely huge,” Onderdonk said. “But I definitely wanted to value the education aspect of it. When you’re getting an opportunity like this to play in such high-level facilities with such high-level guys who could have all played at the Division 1 or Division 3 level, it’s hard to pass up.”
Former Brunswick star Kyle Pagnani actually committed to a Division 1 program out of high school. But after playing his freshman year at Holy Cross, he felt transferring to BC and playing on the club team was the best move.
“I think you have club as a good balance, where you’re able to get a great education at BC but also pursue lacrosse competitively,” Pagnani said.
Senior Brenner Enright, the club president, said the level of play and commitment to the program is serious. BC plays a competitive schedule with a lot of travel. Last year, they played Texas, Arizona State, Syracuse and Virginia Tech. Local schools, including UConn and Northeastern, also rounded out the slate.
Most notably, BC battled UNH in its annual “Red Bandana” game last spring, a tribute to former BC lacrosse player Welles Crowther, who lost his life on Sept. 11, 2001, while saving lives during the attacks in New York City. The game was played at Alumni Stadium in front of a large crowd.
This year, BC has 48 players on its roster, including 20 first-year players who are new to the program. Enright said the atmosphere and team environment are very strong despite it being a club sport.
READ MORE: Can Kari Moss take Acton-Boxboro to the next level?
“I’m still close with seniors who took me on as a freshman,” Enright said. “Great mentors taught you a lot about BC, taught you a lot about growing up and developed you as a lacrosse player in ways that I didn’t really think I could get.”
Enright said getting first-hand accounts from peers played a vital role in choosing the club route in his college planning process. While talking with players who have pursued the NCAA route, he also connected with a player on the BC team to talk about his experience.
“Talking to him and hearing all of his stories about his buddies that played at small Division 3 or Division 1 schools that were a year or two into it and hated it and were burnt out (was important),” Enright said.
The NCAA lacrosse world is constantly evolving, especially surrounding new NCAA eligibility rules that are ultimately shrinking class sizes. It can be a stressful process for players. But Sweet said focusing on academics and fit at any given school is something that should outweigh athletics.
That fit just so happened to be on Commonwealth Avenue.
“I’d really look at the whole school,” Sweet said. “The school’s mission, the classes they offer, the career you’re looking for after and the whole school experience.”


